Beowulf Versus Shrek
Joseph Campbell dedicated his whole life researching patterns that appear In almost every hero story or movie. He discovered that there are a few basics stages that Just about every hero character goes through. This cycle is called “the Monmouth” or more commonly known as “the hereof Journey. ” This paper will compare and contrast Beowulf and Shriek and how each fits into the Monmouth. Every story that Involves a hero will subsequently follow the concept of the Heroes Journey.
In both Shriek and Beowulf, crossing the threshold/threshold guardian stage is quite similar. This stage is defined as the point at which the character(s) cross from their ordinary world Into the unknown world. Also. The guardian part means that they have to pass through a person or obstacle to get to the other side. Crossing the threshold for Beowulf required crossing the shore into Denmark and then going on to fight and kill Greened (Beowulf pigs 144 onward and 285 onward). Metaphorically speaking, crossing the shore and killing Greened is like crossing into the new world as n established hero.
If he had been killed by Greened or denied entry, then none of the other parts of the story would have happened and he would have never gotten to enter the “belly of the whale. ” This stage in Shriek Is almost the same but has a few slight differences. Shriek’s threshold involves his long Journey to Dulls to speak with Lord Faraday. He and Donkey travel by foot all the way to the castle to find themselves walking In on a battle and being attacked by several guards (Shriek). In order to leave his ordinary world as an ogre behind and to embark on a Journey to et his home back, he is forced to defeat these guards.
After he wins the battle, he Is sent on the quest for Princess Fauna (Shriek). If Shriek never made his way to Dulls or got defeated by the guards, he never would have had a chance to go on the quest. In both stories, this stage is almost Identical. They both require traveling a certain distance and then shortly after defeating enemies or an enemy. Those two examples of the first threshold stage prove the truth In Campbell hero Journey. Every story has trials and tests in them. Shriek and Beowulf are no exceptions. To mind out what this stage Is In the story, one could ask him/herself a few questions.
How Is the character “tested” exactly? And how does he/she respond? What are the results? Shriek is tested numerous times on his quest to bring Fauna to Lord Faraday. The first test, and definitely the most difficult one, came when they arrived at the castle. Shriek and Donkey had to cross a rickety bridge of a bubbling pool of lava in order to get Into a castle that had a fire breathing dragon In It. After defeating the dragon using brains more than force, Shriek. Donkey, and now Fauna ran out of the castle, back across the bridge and moved on with the journey.
Another obstacle that Shriek and Donkey have to overcome is how Fauna does not want to comply with being delivered to Lord Faraday. Shriek literally has to carry her for most of the way t Off because seen returned to walk on near own. The last test that Shriek and Donkey tacked was Shriek getting shot with an arrow by Robin Hood and company. The three of them had to fight off Robin Hood and his men in the middle of the woods. Shriek got shot in the back of the leg during this and they had to figure out how to fix it (Shriek). Shriek as many interesting tests in it, most of which are surprisingly similar to those in Beowulf.
Along with most other heroes, Beowulf faces many trials and tests. After he crosses the threshold (battle with Greened), he is then asked to bail out the Danes once again by killing Grenade’s mother. Beowulf has to overcome the challenge of going deep into a lake, seeking out the lair, and defeating the massive creature. One of the problems he faced within the battle was how his sword was not able to pierce Grenade’s mother’s skin. He had to find a sword that was in the lair to get the Job one (Beowulf, pigs 450-623). Another time Beowulf was tested came 50 years later when a dragon was terrorizing his kingdom.
Beowulf, along with a group full of followers, set out to fight yet another beast. Even in his old age, he refused to go against the Anglo Saxon values and decided to fight for his kingdom. Although Beowulf did die in this battle, the monster was still killed by one of his warriors, Wigwag. Therefore, the final goal was still met even with the tragic death of Beowulf (Beowulf, pigs 623-774). This stage in Shriek and Beowulf is quite similar once again. Both of the heroes had to fight different enemies in order to reach the end goal.
It just so happens that both of them faced a fire breathing dragon along the way. This further proves that Campbell Monmouth is extremely accurate. The last stage of the heroes’ Journey that will be analyzed using the stories Shriek and Beowulf is the “master of two worlds” stage. This is achieved when the protagonist feels comfortable and is able to survive in his home world and the other world. Shriek is the master of both worlds when he and Fauna fall in love. Shriek is an ugly ogre but still happily in love. He found a way to find love even though it was difficult.
Beowulf experiences the same phase although it is in a different way. Beowulf is the master of the real world because his legacy lives on to this day. Everyone is reading about him and that is Just how he wanted it. He is also the master of the afterlife because he died an honorable and noble death in battle, assuring his path into the afterlife. The Anglo-Saxon code says that, if one dies in battle, then they will be granted eternal life. Although the stage is a little different in tooth stories, both characters still become the master of two worlds.
That aligns with the theory that all stories follow the “hero cycle,” even if Just a little bit. Every story that involves a hero follows the steps outlined by Joseph Campbell, considered the “hero’s Journey. ” The steps crossing the threshold, trials and tests, and the master of both worlds can be found in both Beowulf and Shriek. Both of these stories are similar in the threshold and trials stages, but a little different in the master of both worlds one. Either way, all three stages are found in both, and there re many more that could be used if needed.
These examples prove that Joseph Campbell is 100% correct with his theory of the Monmouth. Honor Code As a member of the Saint Augustine Prep community, I pledge not to cheat. I will not give nor receive aunt minored assist.